Book bans in the United States have been driven by four recurring motivations—political and religious dissent, obscenity and morality, scientific and ideological conflict, and, most recently, race and identity—and while the targets have changed dramatically since 1637, the underlying impulse to control access to knowledge has not. That is the central finding that emerges from historical accounts and recent research on school library challenges: authorities once burned books as heresy, then prosecuted them as obscenity, and now remove them from shelves over contested content about race, gender, and sexuality. What follows traces each category, then compares them side by side.

The Enduring Practice of Book Censorship

Censorship, as National Geographic has documented, is as old as writing itself, though its targets have shifted over the centuries. In the American colonies, the earliest suppression efforts were spurred by religious leaders, and Britain brought a long-standing tradition of book censorship with it when it founded its territories. A paper published in an American Library Association journal frames the same continuity: book censorship has a vast history in the United States, with obscenity laws playing a major role for decades alongside LGBTQ+ themes, religious values, race, and political ideology. Recent peer-reviewed research on school bans confirms the practice is anything but foreign, noting that U.S. schools and libraries have banned books with some regularity for the past two centuries—before a drastic increase in the 2021–2022 school year.

Political and Religious Dissent: Early Targets of Suppression

The first book ban on American soil was, by the standards of its time, an act of regime protection. According to a Harvard Library research guide, Thomas Morton's New English Canaan, published in 1637 in what is now Quincy, Massachusetts, was banned by the Puritan government because it was considered a harsh and heretical critique of Puritan customs and power structures. The justification was explicit: the text threatened both religious conformity and the governing order built upon it. Religious institutions elsewhere have long done the same—historical examples include the Catholic Church's Index Librorum Prohibitorum and the ban on Salman Rushdie's The Satanic Verses—though such bans did not always carry legal force.

The pattern persists into the present in recognizably similar form. Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale, as the Freedom Forum records, has been challenged in public schools for its treatment of sex and exploitation and for its criticisms of religion in government. In 2023, parents in South Carolina called for its removal after state legislators cited the book during a debate over a proposed abortion ban—though that challenge failed and the book stayed on shelves. The justification has evolved from heresy to classroom appropriateness, but the underlying charge, that a book illegitimately attacks the entanglement of religion and governance, remains recognizable across nearly four centuries.